Ingredients
Equipment
Method
Prep and cook the pasta
- Preheat oven to 350F, then butter a 9x13-inch baking dish for easy release. Visual cue: the dish looks lightly coated, not streaky.
- Cook elbow macaroni 2 minutes less than package directions, then drain well. Visual cue: pasta is still firm and won’t feel fully soft.
Make the cheese sauce
- Melt butter, whisk in all-purpose flour, and cook for 1 minute until smooth. Visual cue: the roux looks glossy and slightly thickened.
- Slowly whisk in whole milk and evaporated milk until fully combined. Visual cue: the mixture turns creamy with no visible flour lumps.
- Simmer for 5-6 minutes until thickened, then season with salt, black pepper, dry mustard, and smoked paprika. Visual cue: sauce clings to the whisk and coats the back of a spoon.
Combine and bake
- Stir in 3 cups shredded sharp cheddar and 1 1/2 cups Gruyere or Colby jack until melted, then fold in the pasta. Visual cue: every noodle is coated in an even, stretchy cheese sauce.
- Pour into the buttered dish and top with the remaining cheese. Visual cue: the surface is covered with a thick, even layer of cheese.
- Bake 25-30 minutes at 350F until bubbly and golden, with browned cheese at the edges. Visual cue: sauce actively bubbles around the perimeter.
- Rest 10 minutes before serving so the casserole sets. Visual cue: the center looks slightly firmer and less loose when you spoon it.
Notes
Pro tip: use freshly shredded cheddar and Gruyere/Colby jack for smoother melting and a better crust. Store leftovers in the refrigerator up to 4 days; reheat in the oven at 350F until hot or microwave individual portions. Freezing is not recommended for best texture. Dietary swap: use lactose-free milk and lactose-free cheddar to reduce lactose without changing the method.
